Reframing the Unknown: Why Feeling Lost Might Be the Best Thing That Ever Happened to You
If you’re stuck between wanting more and not knowing what that “more” even is, you’re in the right place.
By
Josh Felgoise
Oct 20, 2025

The Secret Life of Walter Mitty
The Moment You Realize You’re Not Growing Anymore
There’s a specific kind of silence that settles in when the job you worked so hard to get stops challenging you.
You’re not bad at it. You show up. You do what’s asked. People trust you. On paper, everything looks fine. But somewhere along the way, the spark fades. You stop learning. You stop feeling stretched. You stop feeling proud of how you’re changing.
That realization doesn’t hit all at once. There’s no dramatic breaking point. It shows up quietly, disguised as routine.
The same meetings. The same Slack messages. The same conversations about “growth opportunities” that never actually go anywhere.
And eventually, you catch yourself thinking something you can’t unthink.
“Maybe you start to think, huh, I’m kind of stagnant here and I’m no longer really growing. There’s nobody here that I can learn from and I don’t really see a position that I can grow into.”
That’s the moment everything shifts.
Because once you notice it, you can’t go back.
And that’s terrifying.
When Stability Starts Feeling Like a Trap
Most of us were taught the same rule growing up. Stick it out. Don’t jump too soon. Never leave a job before two years.
That rule sounds responsible. Loyal. Mature.
But it was built for a different world. A world where staying meant security. Where time automatically translated into growth.
“This two-year mark that you’re supposed to hit, that you’re supposed to wait out because someone before us decided it’s the mark of success.”
Longevity doesn’t equal development.
Stability doesn’t guarantee fulfillment.
And staying doesn’t automatically make you stronger.
If you already feel stagnant, waiting another year won’t fix that. It just delays the harder conversation with yourself.
That same realization shows up for a lot of guys in How Do I Choose a Career Path When I Have No Idea What I Want. Direction doesn’t disappear overnight. It fades when growth does.
The Fear That Keeps You Right Where You Are
We tell ourselves we’re staying for logical reasons.
The market’s tough.
The timing isn’t right.
We don’t have the energy to start over.
But underneath all of it is fear.
Fear of disappointing people.
Fear of losing the identity you’ve built.
Fear of stepping into something undefined.
“It is so much easier to stay where you are because of all of the things that I have just said that you have to do to find another job.”
Staying feels safe, even when it’s draining you.
Leaving feels chaotic, even when it might be the thing that wakes you back up.
That’s the trap. We confuse comfort with alignment. We confuse predictability with progress.
Sometimes the chaos is the growth.
The Thought You Keep Putting Back in Your Pocket
There’s a metaphor I love for this phase.
You know when you put on an old pair of jeans and find a $20 bill in the pocket? For a second, everything feels lighter. Possibility shows up again.
That’s what the thought of leaving your job feels like.
“You find it in your pocket again… there’s that thought I had about leaving my job and taking a chance on myself.”
You don’t act on it right away. You just notice it. Then you fold it up and put it back.
But it keeps showing up.
That quiet curiosity.
That sense that there might be more for you than this.
Eventually, you have to decide whether you’re going to keep ignoring it or finally see what it’s worth.
If your mind keeps spinning every time this thought comes up, the way it does in Why Consistency Feels So Hard Even When You Care, that’s not laziness. That’s misalignment asking for attention.
When You Go Off Script
The hardest part of this phase is comparison.
Everyone else looks like they’re moving forward. Promotions. Raises. Titles. Clean timelines that make sense.
And you’re standing there wondering why your life suddenly feels messy.
“Why does it feel like they’ve had a promotion and a raise and climbed the ladder to success while I completely don’t?”
Comparison lies.
You’re not behind.
You’re just off script.
And being off script is where every real change starts.
No one posts the in-between. The part where you don’t have answers yet but you know you can’t stay where you are. That doesn’t mean you failed. It means you noticed something important.
Welcome to the Unconventional Part
This is the space most people never talk about.
The part between jobs.
Between versions of yourself.
Between who you thought you’d be and who you’re becoming.
“You are at what I am calling the unconventional part.”
It’s uncomfortable. It’s disorienting. And it’s exactly where growth lives.
Research from Harvard Business Review backs this up. Career transitions often feel like regression in the moment, even when they lead to long-term fulfillment. The uncertainty isn’t a warning sign. It’s part of the process.
Once you realize most people around you are also figuring it out, just more quietly, the pressure eases. You stop trying to catch up and start asking better questions.
What actually feels right for me?
What kind of life am I building, not just what looks good?
Reframing the Unknown
There’s a line from Night at the Museum that stuck with me.
Ben Stiller’s character says, “I have no idea what I’m going to do tomorrow.”
Robin Williams responds, “How exciting.”
That’s it.
“How exciting.”
“It completely changed my mindset around the unknown and the unconventional part.”
Uncertainty isn’t a void.
It’s a blank canvas.
It’s not proof that you’re lost. It’s proof that you’re still choosing.
The Real Takeaway
You don’t need a five-year plan.
You don’t need everything figured out.
You don’t even need to know your next move yet.
You just need to keep moving.
“Forward is a pace. Forward is emotion.”
And sometimes, forward starts with admitting you’ve outgrown where you are.
FAQ: Feeling Stuck in Your Career
How do I know if I’ve outgrown my job?
When you stop learning, stop feeling challenged, and can’t see a path forward that excites you.
Is it bad to leave a job “too early”?
Not if you’re leaving intentionally. Staying longer doesn’t automatically mean growth.
What if I don’t know what I want to do next?
That’s normal. You don’t need clarity before movement. You build clarity by exploring.
Am I behind if everyone else is getting promoted?
No. Comparison ignores context. You’re on a different path, not a delayed one.
Is feeling anxious about change a red flag?
No. Anxiety usually means you care. Growth often starts where comfort ends.









