I started making the gym a part of my daily routine about a year ago, and it took me a long time to get comfortable with it. I realized the quicker I stopped caring about what other people thought of me or about what I looked like at the gym, the easier it was to find confidence in my abilities and myself. 

Building Gym Confidence: 5 Tips for Guys Who Feel Intimidated at the Gym

The ultimate guide to getting comfortable in the weight room when you're just starting out

Let's be real: walking into a gym for the first time (or the first time in a while) can feel like stepping onto an alien planet. Everyone seems to know exactly what they're doing while you're standing there wondering if you should be using the scary-looking machine with all the cables or if you should just stick to the treadmill where it's safe.

If you've ever felt that gym intimidation—that voice in your head saying "everyone is looking at me" or "I don't belong here"—you're not alone. Building gym confidence doesn't happen overnight, but with the right mindset shifts, you can go from feeling like an imposter to owning your workout space.

The Intimidation Factor: Stop Comparing Yourself to Others

As Theodore Roosevelt wisely said, "Comparison is the thief of joy."

When you first start going to the gym, it's almost impossible not to look around at everyone else. And yes, there will always be someone who:

• Is bigger than you

• Can lift more than you

• Looks more fit than you

• Seems to know what they're doing

Here's the truth: that person who's bench pressing 300 pounds didn't start there. The guy with the impressive physique didn't look like that when he first walked into a gym. And the person confidently using that complicated machine? They once had no idea what they were doing either.

The mindset shift: Stop comparing yourself to other people and start comparing yourself to your previous self.

If a year ago you weren't going to the gym at all, and now you're showing up consistently—that's progress. If you started curling 15-pound weights and now you're at 30 pounds—that's progress. These are the comparisons that matter and the ones that will keep you motivated rather than discouraged.

Getting 1% Better Each Day: Embrace the Long Game

Transformations don't happen overnight. You're not going to do a 10-minute ab workout and wake up looking like Zac Efron the next morning (wouldn't that be nice?).

The secret to sustainable progress is focusing on getting just 1% better each day. These small improvements compound over time into significant changes—but they require patience and consistency.

For example, I've been doing ab workouts for about a year, and I'm just now starting to see visible progress. That might sound discouraging, but it's actually liberating. When you accept that fitness is a long game, you remove the pressure of immediate results and can focus instead on showing up and putting in the work.

The mindset shift: Replace "I need to see results now" with "I'm investing in my future self with each workout."

Getting Comfortable with Being Uncomfortable

Growth happens outside your comfort zone—it's a cliché because it's true, especially at the gym.

Getting comfortable with being uncomfortable means:

• Being okay with failing at a rep

• Not knowing how to use every piece of equipment

• Looking sweaty and exhausted

• Taking up space even when you feel like you don't deserve to

The only way to learn is by trying, and trying means sometimes failing. That first time you can't complete a set, or you have to drop down in weight, or you need to ask how to use a machine—those moments feel mortifying. But they're also the exact moments that build both your physical and mental strength.

The mindset shift: Reframe discomfort as a sign of growth rather than a sign of inadequacy.

Creating a Consistent Routine

Consistency isn't just about physical progress—it's about making the gym a normal part of your life rather than a special, intimidating event.

To build a sustainable gym routine:

1. Choose specific days and times - Whether it's Tuesday/Thursday mornings or Monday/Wednesday/Friday evenings, having a set schedule removes the daily decision of whether to go.

2. Plan your workouts in advance - Know what you'll be training each day (e.g., upper body, lower body, full body, cardio) so you walk in with purpose.

3. Start with a manageable frequency - Two or three days a week is perfect for beginners. You can always add more as your fitness and confidence improve.

4. Give yourself grace - If you miss a day, it's not the end of your fitness journey. The beauty of tomorrow is that it's another opportunity to show up.

Remember: consistency is the key to success in anything, especially fitness. When going to the gym becomes as routine as brushing your teeth, the intimidation factor starts to fade.

The mindset shift: View the gym as a regular part of your schedule rather than a special event that requires perfect performance.

Finding What Works for You

Not everyone thrives with the same workout style or environment. Finding what works for you is essential for building lasting gym confidence.

For me, using guided workouts through apps like Peloton (not an ad, just what works for me) has been a game-changer. Having an instructor tell me exactly what to do removes the uncertainty that used to make me anxious. I'm now comfortable propping up my phone and following along, regardless of who might be watching.

Other options include:

• Following YouTube workout videos

• Using a notebook with exercises written down

• Hiring a trainer for a few sessions to learn the basics

• Working out with a more experienced friend

• Using gym equipment that makes you feel most comfortable initially

The mindset shift: There's no "right way" to work out—there's only the way that works for you and keeps you coming back.

The Equipment Intimidation

We've talked about feeling intimidated by other people, but let's be honest—the equipment itself can be just as intimidating. When you look at some machines, it's not immediately obvious what body part they're supposed to target or how to adjust them safely.

Don't be afraid to:

• Watch instructional videos before trying new equipment

• Ask staff for a quick demonstration

• Start with simpler equipment and gradually expand your comfort zone

• Observe how others use machines (just don't stare too long!)

Remember, even the most experienced gym-goers had to learn how to use equipment at some point. There's no shame in being a beginner.

On Gym Memberships: The Value Proposition

While budget is always a consideration, think about gym memberships in terms of value rather than just cost. If you're paying $60-100 per month but going 4-5 times per week, that breaks down to $5-10 per visit—less than a cocktail or movie ticket.

A gym where you feel comfortable and motivated is worth the investment because you'll actually go. Consider factors like:

• Equipment quality and availability

• Crowding during your preferred workout times

• Cleanliness and overall vibe

• Location (the best gym is one you'll actually go to)

The Bottom Line: Nobody Is Watching You (That Closely)

The biggest revelation in building gym confidence is realizing that most people are too focused on their own workouts to pay much attention to yours. That intense self-consciousness you feel is rarely matched by actual scrutiny from others.

The quicker you can stop worrying about what others think of you, the faster you'll gain confidence in the gym. When I stopped giving a fuck about looking like I didn't know what I was doing, I paradoxically started looking more like I belonged there.

Remember:

• Everyone started somewhere

• Progress happens through consistency, not perfection

• Getting comfortable with being uncomfortable is the fastest path to growth

• The only person you should compare yourself to is your past self

Building gym confidence isn't about becoming the biggest or strongest person in the room—it's about becoming comfortable enough in your own skin to focus on your workout rather than your insecurities.

So grab your water bottle, queue up a workout on your phone if that helps, and take up the space you deserve. Your future self will thank you for pushing through the initial discomfort.

Got questions about building gym confidence or want to share your own journey? Drop a comment below or reach out directly. For more honest conversations about fitness, self-improvement, and navigating your twenties as a guy, check out the Guyset podcast wherever you listen to podcasts.

Keywords: gym confidence, gym anxiety, workout intimidation, beginner gym tips, fitness motivation, gym for beginners, weight room confidence, overcoming gym intimidation, fitness journey, workout consistency, gym routine for beginners

Listen for 5 tips to build what I call "gym confidence". 

Thanks for listening! Subscribe or follow, give this episode 5 stars, and leave a review! 

Send in any questions, things you want me to talk about, or things that should be talked about for guys in their 20s to josh@guyset.com  

Click HERE to follow Guyset on TikTok

Click HERE to follow Guyset on Instagram

Click HERE to check out Guyset.com

See you next Tuesday.