The Condom Conversation Every Guy Avoids (But Shouldn’t)

Luke’s “if it ain’t broke” approach proves condoms aren’t complicated. When it comes to sex, consistency and confidence go hand in hand.

By
Josh Felgoise

Mar 1, 2025

Trojan Ultra Ribbed. That’s What I Said.

“Trojan Ultra Ribbed... That’s what I said in the last one. I’ve always used the same one... If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it. Literally.”

Luke’s answer was instant. No hesitation.
And that’s the point. When it comes to condoms, most guys overthink what doesn’t need overthinking.

If you’ve found what works, stick with it.

The Consistency Advantage

This isn’t about variety. It’s about reliability.
Condoms are one of those things where consistency matters more than experimentation.

Luke’s routine proves it:

  • Predictable fit and feel: You know what to expect every time.

  • Reliable protection: The same brand means the same standards.

  • No surprises: No reactions or weird sizing changes.

  • Confidence: Familiarity makes everything smoother.

When you know what works, you eliminate variables. And that’s confidence.

“If It Ain’t Broke, Don’t Fix It”

It’s simple logic that most guys overlook.
Condoms aren’t about collecting variety, they’re about protecting what matters.

Luke’s approach covers all the basics:

  • Consistent protection

  • Reliable performance

  • Peace of mind

  • Zero unnecessary risk

It’s not boring. It’s smart.

When Consistency Matters Most

Safety first.
You don’t want surprises here. When you stick with a trusted brand, you know:

  • The material and quality standards

  • The protection level you expect

  • That your body reacts fine to it

That’s one less thing to think about when the moment matters.

Performance Reliability

Switching brands just for variety can cause more harm than good.
Different fits, textures, or materials can throw things off.
Luke’s consistency shows confidence. He’s found what works and isn’t interested in overcomplicating it.

Finding Your Standard

If you haven’t found your go-to yet:

  1. Try a few reputable brands.

  2. Figure out what fits and feels right.

  3. Stick with it.

Once you find it, you’re set. That’s one decision you never need to revisit.

The Smart Guy Advantage

When you know what you like, you can:

  • Buy in bulk for better value.

  • Always be stocked and ready.

  • Skip the awkward store runs.

Preparation is maturity. It’s that simple.

Why This Works

Less decision fatigue.
No overthinking, no last-minute choices. You’ve already got your setup.

Relationship benefits.
Consistency shows reliability and responsibility. It’s maturity in action.

When to Reconsider

There are a few reasons to switch it up:

  • If comfort changes

  • If your partner has preferences

  • If the brand changes or becomes hard to find

When that happens, do a little research. Try small packs first.
But don’t switch just to switch.

The Bigger Picture

Sexual health isn’t a guessing game.
Luke’s “if it ain’t broke” mindset is what being a grown man looks like. Prepared, confident, and consistent.

Reliability beats novelty every time.

The Takeaway

Luke’s approach is proof that simplicity works.

“I’ve always used the same one... If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it. Literally.”

Find what fits. Trust it. Stick with it.
That’s not boring. That’s smart.

Want more real conversations about the stuff guys don’t usually talk about?
Subscribe to Guyset for weekly takes on health, relationships, and the everyday realities of being a guy figuring it out.