Real Answers to the Dating Questions Guys Are Actually Searching For

Ghosting, first texts, rescheduling, losing interest, and everything in between

By
Josh Felgoise

Nov 18, 2025

Early dating comes with questions you do not always know who to ask. You want clarity without overthinking. You want confidence without pretending. And most of the questions that mess with guys happen in the first two or three weeks of getting to know someone.

These are the real, high intent questions guys search at 1 a.m. when they are trying to understand the situation without embarrassing themselves.

Let’s dive in.

Q: How long should I wait for someone to reschedule a date?

Here is the cleanest way to think about it.

If she cancels, she should offer a new time quickly. Not instantly, not in 30 seconds, but without days of silence.

“I do not think an entire day should go by or you should give somebody a full week to go by because it leaves the other person feeling anxious and waiting for your response”

A reschedule is only respectful when it comes with clarity.
If she cancels and follows up with something like:

Can we do Wednesday instead
What about this weekend
Is Thursday at 7 good for you

That is good energy.

If she cancels and disappears for days, that is not a reschedule. That is a slow fade.

If this is a pattern you keep running into, read Why Did I Get Ghosted because unclear reschedules are often the first sign of a disappearing act.

Q: What should I text a girl after getting her number at the bar?

Guys overcomplicate this. The perfect text is already in your vocabulary.

Keep it simple. Keep it human.

“Hey, it is Josh from down the hatch. It was really great to meet you”

That line works because she instantly remembers who you are. You are giving her context, not guessing.

Then follow it with intention.

“I would love to grab drinks sometime this week”

That is the move. Clear, relaxed, and confident.

If you want more detail on timing and tone, go read When Should I Text a Girl After Getting Her Number.

And if you want to read her energy from the first conversation, this is essential:
How To Know If a Girl Is Actually Interested.

Q: What should I do if I think she is losing interest?

This is the moment that sends guys into a spiral. You feel the shift, even if you cannot explain it.

“I feel like I am the only one driving the boat here and she is like laying on the sun deck in the back”

When that happens, you have two choices.

You can guess.
Or you can get clarity.

Guessing will take you down a hundred imaginary scenarios and none of them will be fair to you.

Honesty grounds you.

A simple, direct:

“Hey, I am not seeing anybody else right now. And I do not want to.”

You are not locking anything in. You are not rushing a label. You are simply opening the door to a real conversation.

If conversation confidence is something you want to work on, this helps:
How To Build Confidence in Conversation.

Q: How do I know if the connection is real or if I am just overthinking?

Comfort is the answer.
It is the feeling underneath everything.

“It is that ease and that comfortability when you are in the other person’s presence and you feel calm around them and you feel like you are yourself”

That feeling is rare.
You cannot fake it.
You cannot manufacture it.

And it matters more than chemistry.

Chemistry is sparks.
Comfort is stability.

If your early dates feel stressful instead of exciting, this will help you reset your mindset before the next one: What Should I Do Before a First Date.

Q: How am I supposed to know if this is right?

Forget the pressure of imagining your whole future. That is overwhelming. That creates fear instead of clarity.

There is one simple test.

Picture your next week without them.

“If you think about what your next week would be like without them and you think I would be devastated to not have them in my life, then you know that that is probably right”

Three outcomes usually show up:

1. Your week feels the same.
That is a sign the connection is light, not deep.

2. You feel curious.
That means you should give it another date.

3. You feel sad imagining it.
That means something real is forming.

If you have been feeling behind on dating, life, or timing in your 20s, this is a must read:
How To Stop Feeling Behind in Your 20s.

Q: Should I reach back out to someone who ghosted me?

The short answer is no.

The real answer is still no.

“Ghosting is the worst feeling. You are just left wondering like why did she not respond to me. What did I do wrong”

And as hard as it is to accept, reaching out does not fix that.

“Should you reach back out. Absolutely not. You probably should not because I feel like you should have more self respect than that”

Ghosting is not a mystery to solve.
It is clarity.
It is someone showing you their emotional availability without saying a word.

If someone wants to talk to you, they will.
If someone values you, you will not have to chase them.

If this has been a recurring pattern in your life, go read Why Did I Get Ghosted and reset the expectations you are walking into dating with.

Q: What should I do when dating feels overwhelming or confusing?

The biggest shift is going from guessing to clarity.

Clarity in plans.
Clarity in communication.
Clarity in intention.

It simplifies everything.
It shows confidence.
It removes games.
It filters out the wrong people fast.

And when you combine that with comfort, it makes dating feel easier and more honest.

Most of the confusion guys feel in early dating comes from silence, mixed signals, and assuming instead of asking.

Get curious.
Get direct.
Get grounded.

Dating becomes way lighter when you stop trying to look perfect and start trying to be clear.

Listen Now

Want the full story behind all of this
Listen to “Getting Ghosted, First Texts, and Rescheduling Dates: Dear Guyset” on Spotify or Apple Podcasts.

Want to hear the full story Listen to the episode on Spotify or Apple Podcasts.