How to Actually Deal with a Breakup: The Only Thing That Really Works
Why the most clichéd advice is actually the most true
By
Josh Felgoise
May 30, 2025
"It's so cliche... but it's the most true thing ever. The only thing that heals the pain of a breakup is time. Like literally that's the only thing."
Luke's insight about breakup recovery cuts through all the complicated advice and self-help strategies to reveal an uncomfortable truth: there's no shortcut through heartbreak. But understanding this reality, and knowing how to use that time productively, can make all the difference.
The Breakup That Changed Everything
Luke's most difficult breakup happened in high school - his first real relationship. What made it particularly devastating wasn't just the end of the relationship itself, but his circumstances afterward.
"I didn't have like the closest knit group of friends in high school... Just didn't really have... that core group."
This experience taught him something crucial: "That's never a good recipe to go into a relationship with if you don't have like that core group."
The lesson isn't just about breakup recovery - it's about the foundation you need in place before entering serious relationships.
Why Time Is Really the Only Answer
The Uncomfortable Truth
"I was actually just talking about this with a coworker of mine. It's so cliche... but it's the most true thing ever."
Luke acknowledges how frustrating this advice sounds when you're in pain. Everyone wants a faster solution, a technique, or a strategy that will make the hurt go away immediately. But breakup pain isn't a problem to be solved - it's a process to be experienced.
What "Time Heals" Actually Means
Time doesn't just magically make you feel better. What happens over time is:
Emotional intensity naturally decreases
Perspective develops on what the relationship actually was
New experiences gradually replace old memories
Identity rebuilds independent of the relationship
Attachment patterns slowly adjust to the new reality
Using Time Productively: The Retrospection Process
The Essential Questions
"You need to do some retrospection on... what went wrong. What did you do wrong. Because every relationship anyone's ever been in both people have done something... There are things that both people did incorrectly that led to it."
Luke emphasizes that breakup recovery requires honest self-examination:
What patterns contributed to the relationship's end?
What did you do that you'd handle differently next time?
What did you learn about your needs and compatibility?
How did you show up in the relationship, both positively and negatively?
The Compatibility Discovery
"I think that the most you learn things about who you're compatible with, like whether or if it's things like don't work for you compatibility wise... These were the parts that I liked about it. This is what I need out of a part... these are things that I can't... you find what's compatible with you and what isn't."
Each relationship teaches you:
What dynamics work well for you
What behaviors or traits you can't tolerate
What you need from a partner to feel fulfilled
How you function in different types of relationships
Filling the Void: The Practical Challenge
The Time Problem
"I spent so much of my time talking to this person and like having this person in my life. Like how do I fill that time? Cause it's like, it's like a void there."
This is the most immediate practical challenge after a breakup. You suddenly have hours of time that were previously occupied by:
Texting and calling
Making plans together
Spending time together
Thinking about the relationship
Luke's Solution Strategy
"I think whether it's like... the gym is a great one or like going for runs... I think that's a great way because it's two birds, stone. You know, you're doing something that's benefiting you and you're also not..."
His approach focuses on activities that:
Improve your physical and mental health
Require focus and attention (preventing rumination)
Build positive momentum in your life
Create new routines independent of the relationship
The Introspection Framework
What to Focus On
"I think it's a good time to just think about, what you're passionate about. What can you improve about yourself? whether it's the way you approach relationships or just in general."
Luke suggests using breakup recovery time for:
Personal Inventory:
What are you genuinely passionate about?
What aspects of yourself want development?
What goals have you been neglecting?
What would make you feel proud of yourself?
Relationship Skills:
How do you communicate during conflict?
What triggers emotional reactions in you?
How do you show love and appreciation?
What boundaries do you need to maintain?
Life Direction:
What do you want your next relationship to look like?
What other areas of life need attention?
How can you build a life you're excited about independent of dating?
The Support System Factor
Learning from Luke's Mistake
His most difficult breakup was made worse by lacking a strong friend group. This experience taught him the importance of:
Building friendships before you need them
Maintaining relationships outside of romantic partnerships
Having people you can talk to during difficult times
Creating a social network that exists independent of dating
Building Your Support Network
If you don't currently have a strong support system:
Invest time in existing friendships before crisis hits
Join activities or groups where you can meet like-minded people
Be the kind of friend you'd want during difficult times
Don't rely solely on romantic relationships for emotional support
What Not to Do During Breakup Recovery
Avoid the Quick Fixes
While Luke doesn't explicitly mention these, his emphasis on time suggests avoiding:
Rebound relationships as distraction from pain
Excessive partying or drinking to numb feelings
Obsessive social media checking of your ex
Trying to stay friends immediately before processing the breakup
Don't Rush the Process
"The only thing that heals the pain of a breakup is time."
This means accepting that:
You can't think your way out of heartbreak
Feeling better will happen gradually, not suddenly
Some days will be harder than others, and that's normal
There's no "right" timeline for getting over someone
The Long-Term Perspective
Every Relationship Teaches You Something
"I learned so much about myself... any like time you spent with somebody, like whether it's like a year, six months, like you always learn something about yourself from it."
Luke's perspective on his relationships is that each one contributed to his understanding of:
What he wants in a partner
How he functions in relationships
What his patterns and triggers are
What kind of life he wants to build
Building Toward Better Relationships
The goal of breakup recovery isn't just to feel better - it's to:
Understand yourself more deeply
Develop better relationship skills
Build a stronger foundation for future connections
Create a life you're happy with independent of romantic relationships
Your Breakup Recovery Action Plan
Immediate Phase (First Few Weeks)
Accept that this will take time - stop looking for quick fixes
Establish new routines to fill the time void
Reach out to friends and family for support
Focus on basic self-care - sleep, nutrition, exercise
Processing Phase (First Few Months)
Begin honest self-reflection about the relationship
Identify patterns you want to change going forward
Invest in physical and mental health activities
Pursue interests that were neglected during the relationship
Growth Phase (Ongoing)
Apply lessons learned to how you approach future relationships
Continue building a strong, independent life
Maintain the friendships and activities that supported you
Stay patient with the healing process
The Bottom Line
Luke's approach to breakup recovery is both realistic and hopeful. Yes, it's going to take time - there's no way around that. But that time doesn't have to be wasted.
"The only thing that heals the pain of a breakup is time. Like literally that's the only thing."
By using that time for genuine self-reflection, building healthier habits, and strengthening your support network, you emerge from the breakup not just healed, but genuinely improved.
The goal isn't to get back to who you were before the relationship - it's to become someone better equipped for healthy relationships in the future. And that transformation, while painful, can only happen with time.
Want more honest advice about relationships and personal growth in your twenties? Subscribe to Guyset for weekly insights on dating, breakups, and building a life you're proud of.